Categories
Manga Reviews

Pride Volumes 1 and 2 from Jmanga.com

Pride was a series I snapped up immediately when I saw it show up as a new shojo title on Jmanga.com. This manga details the story of two competing opera singers, one from an elite background and one trying to struggle her way up from poverty. In a twist from what one might expect, the rich girl is sympathetic if reserved while the poor girl exhibits lying psychopath tendencies. I do enjoy manga stories set with show business as a background, as they tend to be a great shoujo or josei variation on the type of striving and competition that I usually expect from sports manga. Pride would appeal to fans of dramatic, slightly retro shojo stories like the Glass Mask anime or my beloved ballet classic Swan.

The first two volumes of Pride are available at a bargain price as part of Jmanga’s Shojo from Shueisha sale.

The first volume is also available for free on Jmanga7.

Pride Volume 1 by Yukari Ichijo

Shio Asami is a poor little rich girl opera diva in training when she has an odd encounter with another high school girl, Moe Midorikawa who is working for a housecleaning service. Shio finds out that her father isn’t going to attend the opera with her so she gives her extra ticket to Moe. The girls go to the opera, where Shio is greeted warmly by opera society since she’s the daughter of a famous dead opera singer. Two people take notice of both Shio and Moe. Natsuko runs a club in the Ginza, and thinks that Shio looks just like her mother. Record company executive Mr. Jinno thinks that it has been a long time since he’s met “such an upstanding mademoiselle” when he looks at Shio, but gives Moe the advice that if she wants to get to the top it “doesn’t matter what shameless tricks you have to play.” Moe makes a bunch of comments about about Shio’s privileged lifestyle, but Shio is bored with it all saying, “I’m not the type to gloat over other people’s jealously. Rather I find it unpleasant.”

When Shio gets home she abruptly finds out that her life is going to change when her father confesses to her that his company is bankrupt and he’s about to move to New Zealand to work on a friend’s sheep farm. Rather than cause a scene, Moe looks shocked, thinks a bit, tosses back a glass of champagne, and asks about her father’s plans. This was the moment where I decided I was on Team Shio for the rest of the manga! Shio has a little bit of money in savings which will allow her to get a job in Japan, but she’s going to have to go to work instead of continuing her music studies in college. Moe and Shio then meet again when they are both entered in the same singing competition. Moe wins due to some careful costume selection, acting ability, and her making a horrible reference to the death of Shio’s mother right before Shio goes onstage to sing her final song. Then after the competition there’s a DIVAFIGHT!

Ichijo’s art is clear and easy to follow, with a bit of an old-fashioned style. I wasn’t surprised to see that she’s been working in manga since the 1970s, with Pride originally coming out in Japan in the early 2000s. Pride seems a bit more josei than shojo, with both the girls out of school and facing difficulties as they enter adult life. Shio’s pride prevents her from asking anyone for help as she settles in to an apartment on her own. She goes out of her way to maintain a happy facade for her father so he will continue with his own plans to move away. Shio finds some unexpected support from Ran, a composer in the piano division at her school whose mother Natsuko wants Shio to work in her club. Shio ends up stumbling into an unlikely friendship with Ran and is relieved at the idea that she might actually have a job singing, even if she has to learn a repertoire of non-opera songs.

Pride Volume 2 by Yukari Ichijo

The slightly slimy Jinno ends up influencing the lives of both Moe and Natsuko. Moe’s relentless drive to exploit her one contact in the music industry has her working as Jinno’s maid, and later prostrating herself and asking for his help after a confrontation with her deranged mother. Moe’s behavior is a contrast to Shio’s inability to ask anyone for a favor. Jinno provides Moe with advice and music lessons, and Moe is determined to learn how to act like a more mature woman in order to attract him. She also gets a job at Natsuko’s club after demonstrating her ability to charm elderly men. By the end of the second volume a long-term rivalry between Shio and Moe is established, as Moe’s untrained and more expressive voice attracts Ran’s interest as the vehicle to express his original compositions. Jinno wants Shio to be his perfect society companion since she has no difficulty moving in music industry circles. Moe and Shio both have what the other most desperately wants, and it will be interesting to see if Shio is able to toughen up and become more streetwise in order to deal with her unscrupulous rival. While I have a clear favorite character to follow in this series in Shio, Moe’s background is filled in a bit and it is clear that she acts desperate because she comes from desperate circumstances. It’ll be interesting to see how everything plays out in future volumes.

My one criticism of the series is that with such a clear focus on the lives of the heroines, a chance to drop in some extra knowledge of opera and music got passed up. While it is true that sometimes I put down a volume of Swan with a feeling that I’d just read an encyclopedia article about the development of Russian Ballet, I enjoyed getting some random factoids to balance out the angst. I would have liked Pride even more if there were a few more details about vocal training or more background information about opera. There was plenty of drama packed into the first two volumes, and I am definitely on board with this series. As long as there’s a DIVAFIGHT every couple of issues I suspect that I will continue to be very entertained.

Electronic access provided by the publisher.

Categories
Manga Reviews

Crazy for You Volumes 1 and 2 on JManga.com

Crazy for You Volumes 1 and 2 by Karuho Shiina

Available on Jmanga.com

I was very excited when I saw that JManga had started adding new shojo titles – two volumes at a time! Jmanga started up with plenty of shonen and seinen titles, but the josei and shojo categories were a bit underserved until recently. I was particularly interested in Crazy For You, since it is by the author of the quirky and heartwarming series Kimi Ni Todoke. With the contraction of the manga market and many publishers with significant shojo titles going out of business, there’s only so much capacity for print shojo, so I’m very happy to see JManga releasing more female-centric titles.

Crazy for You is an earlier series by Shiina, and while the art isn’t as sophisticated, Shiina puts together a very compelling plot with a bit of a twist from what the reader would expect from a shojo manga. In many ways Sachi is the stereotypical shojo heroine. She’s not the prettiest or smartest girl in school, and in fact she has never had a boyfriend. She does exhibit an almost ruthlessly optimistic way of viewing the world. Sachi’s good friend Akemi invites her along on a group date with a bunch of boys who go to her boyfriend’s school. Sachi meets Yuki, who pronounces her “cute” and since Sachi is easily impressed she thinks “I think I can survive for half a year on rice topped with just those words!” If Crazy For You was only an exploration of Sachi’s simple first romance, it would get boring very fast but fortunately Shiina starts mixing things up very quickly. It turns out that Yuki is an unapologetic womanizer, and Akemi warns her off of developing any sort of attachment to him. Yuki finds Sachi’s innocence amusing and refreshing, but decides that he would be a horrible person if he actually took advantage of her trust, so he decides not to date her. Despite all of these undercurrents, Sachi and Yuki end up developing an odd-not quite romantic friendship although Sachi is quite forthright about her feelings for Yuki. Akemi keeps trying to tell Sachi that Yuki is going to make her cry, and Yuki’s sardonic friend Akahoshi observes Yuki and Sachi’s budding relationship with his own hidden motivations. The first volume of the manga ends with a very surprising plot twist that is the type of development I would normally expect several volumes into the series. I was enjoying Sachi and Yuki’s odd friendship, but the conclusion really got me hooked on the series.

The art starts to smooth out a bit in the second volume, with some of the paneling in the later chapters reminding me more of the style shown in Kimi Ni Todoke. There’s plenty of dramatic fall-out to deal with, and Akahoshi warns Yuki that if he’s not going to date Sachi, he’s going to take her away. Sachi’s friendship with Akemi is strained, but she deals with it in a refreshingly direct manner. Akahoshi tells Sachi that it is impossible for men and women to be friends, and warns her away from her usual habit of trying to see the best in people.

Sachi’s portrayed as sweet and trusting, but she isn’t a Pollyanna caricature. She’s throwing herself into experiencing a new side of life and dealing with everything as best she can. One of the things I liked about Crazy for You is that I wasn’t really sure which direction the plot was going to go. Sachi has the potential for a romantic relationship with Yuki if a variety of obstacles – both external and internal are solved. On the other hand, Akahoshi’s somewhat harsh exterior and blunt way of speaking may be a front for someone who is genuinely caring, and his tendency to not try to shield Sachi from harsh reality might make him a better match for her in the long run. I hope that we see more shojo titles like Crazy for You on Jmanga.

Electronic access provided by the publisher.

Categories
Manga Reviews

Alice in the Country of Clover: Cheshire Cat Waltz

Alice in the Country of Clover: Cheshire Cat Waltz Volume 1 by QuinRose and Mamenosuke Fujimaru

I’m always a little hesitant to review manga from genres I don’t generally enjoy. After all, if I was reading a western and my reaction was “I don’t like books with horses and cowboys!” that’s not very helpful to potential readers. Part of the reason why I liked Alice in the Country of Hearts so much was that it seemed to transcend the whole manga adaptation of a dating game genre a little bit, just because it was occasionally surreal and weird. Alice in the Country of Hearts certainly succeeded in at least being a manga with an interesting atmosphere, even if the plot wasn’t the strongest point of the manga. I think that hard core fans of the first series will certainly enjoy Cheshire Cat Waltz, but I didn’t like it very much just because it exhibited a certain lack of subtly and less intriguing storyline.

One of the interesting things about Alice in the Country of Hearts was the worldbuilding as Alice discovers the strange new world (populated by handsome men) that she’s been transported to. Alice in the Country of Clover starts midway in a different reality where Alice’s home base was the amusement park instead of the clock tower. The world suddenly gets transported from Hearts to the Country of Clover, and Alice has to adjust to a new reality while fighting her attraction to Boris, the Cheshire Cat. Starting midstream can be both good and bad. Readers already familiar with the setting of this magna aren’t bogged down by exposition. On the other hand, any references to the pasts of the characters feels a bit unearned, because the reader hasn’t seen the history that’s being referred to. Alice keeps mentioning how much she misses her old life at the amusement park after she’s whisked away to the Country of Clover, but since her time at the amusement park was never fully portrayed, her dilema doesn’t have much emotional depth.

Fujimaru ably executes all the varied character designs established in the earlier series, but I tend to prefer the delicate illustrations that were a bit more sparse on screen tone in Hearts. There isn’t really anything to complain about with Clover’s art, but it just seems less visually distinct than the look that Soumei Hoshino established in Hearts. Clover’s art was more typical and the actions of the characters were also much less subtle. Blood skulks around trying out bad innuendo on Alice in all of his dialogue, and Alice gets randomly groped on a number of occasions. This stands in contract to the surreal violence and suggestions of psychological trauma that were hinted at in the earlier series. So overall, my reaction to Alice in the Country of Clover was that it was too much like a dating sim manga for me to really enjoy, and I’m going to have to assume that Alice in the Country of Hearts was the notable exception in this series in terms of being more rewarding to read. That being said, I’m probably not completely done with this franchise – I would certainly pick up another volume if Hoshino is on art duties again, and I’d also be curious to read a manga in the series that features Ace, the directionally impaired and homicidal Knight.

Categories
Manga Reviews

Full Moon O Sagashite Volumes 5-7 by Arina Tanemura

I was hoping to finish up this series by the end of last week for the Manga Moveable Feast, but that didn’t end up happening. I did throughly enjoy the last half of Full Moon O Sagashite. One of the reasons why I liked the series so much when I started reading it was because Mitsuki didn’t seem to have the personality I’d expect from a typical dying shojo heroine with the alter ego of an idol singer. The sentimentality does get ratcheted up in the later volumes, but the sentiments expressed never feel unearned. One big thing that goes into making the series feel fully realized is the way Mitsuki’s shinigami companions all have their own motivations that sometimes conflict with each other. How and if Mitsuki should be supported in her ambitions is something that is debated and at times thwarted. After getting this far into the series I wasn’t annoyed by the the generational connections and coincidences that bound Mizuki’s extended family together with the shinigami, instead I was amused as more of the backstory was filled in and we started to see that Mizuki’s support system wasn’t sent to her randomly at all.

I don’t want to give away too much about the ending of the series except to say it was happy and not unexpected. I wasn’t disappointed by not being surprised by the conclusion of the series, instead by the end of the seven volumes filled with ups and downs and occasional suffering it was good to see everything headed in a positive direction. While I read and enjoy plenty of manga, it is somewhat rare for me to finish a serie with a feeling of fondness. Any shojo fans looking for a dose of warm fuzzies will be well served by Full Moon O Sagashite.

Categories
Manga Reviews

Kamisama Kiss Volume 10

Kamisama Kiss volume 10 by Julietta Suzuki

Kamisama Kiss continues to be one of the most consistently charming shojo manga being published today. I need to fill in the gaps in my collection, because I tend to read random volumes here and there, but it is very fun to read. I was delighted to discover that shrine goddess in training Nananmi and cynical fox spirit Tomoe’s relationship has progressed somewhat. Of course in shoujo manga land, relationship progression means making overtures of affection or declarations of love when the object of one’s affection is unconscious, but I’ll take whatever I can get.

Nanami finds herself entangled in a rengu succession battle, as she has to sneak into Mount Kuruma and determine what is happening to the hapless Tengu under the rule of the overly strict heir Jiro. She also needs to track down the reasons behind the mysterious disappearance of the ruler of Mount Kuruma, Sojobo. Nanami gleefully comes up with a reckless infiltration plan involving a variety of disguises and the aid of the youngest and most vulnerable tengu. The interaction between the characters in Kamisama Kiss is always fun to see, and it was interesting to see Nanami’s newfound confidence as she dons the disguise of a male tengu and then proceeds to boldly run through the entire hall inorder to set up her own magical shield. Tomoe detects Jiro’s fascination with Nanami and assumes her form in order to provide a necessary distraction, and Tomoe’s version of Nanami is hilarious to watch in action because his body language of languid flirtation stands in such contrast to Nanami’s usual open enthusiasm. Not many artists could pull off a scene like that very well, and I always put down each issue of Kamisama Kiss with renewed appreciation for Suzuki’s illustration skills.

Review copy provided by the publisher.